Where to Buy Uncooked Turkey in Amarillo, TX (2025)

Written By Megg Dunlap

Plus a Lingo Decoder & Thanksgiving Portion Guide

Follow @YellowCityTable on Instagram for all the answers to your burning Thanksgiving questions!

This is your Amarillo guide to buying an uncooked bird in 2025—what stores to check, what label terms actually matter, and exactly how much turkey to buy for your crew.

We’ll keep this updated as we recieve more information from the community so you’re in the know!

TL;DR

  • Our pick: Pre-order an Organic Heirloom (Mary’s) from Natural Grocers – Hillside Rd if you want premium flavor + standards. Supplies are limited; call to reserve.

  • Best local bets for walk-in: Market Street (Georgia & Coulter) and United/Amigos for big frozen selections, limited fresh drops, bone-in breasts, and parts.

  • Have a plan: know your target weight (1–1¼ lb/adult), your timeline (thaw/brine/dry time), and a backup (bone-in breast or second smaller bird).

  • Label cheat: “contains up to X% solution” = pre-salted (season less). “Air-chilled/low retained water” = better browning.

Where to buy (uncooked only)

Natural Grocers — 7441 Hillside Rd

  • Best for: premium standards (Organic, Heritage/Heirloom) with transparent labeling.

  • How it works: Pre-order online by size range, then pick up when shipments land; selection within your range is first-come. If you’re standards-driven or chasing heirloom flavor, this is the smoothest local path.

  • Links: Store info → https://www.naturalgrocers.com/store/amarillo • Reserve → https://turkeys.naturalgrocers.com/ng_store/amarillo/

  • Pro tips:

    • When reserving, note your preferred range (e.g., 12–14 lb) and arrive early to snag the top of that range.

    • Call the meat counter the week of pickup to confirm arrival day/time and whether any birds are brined/solution-added (and the %/ingredients).

    • Ask if neck/giblets are included (they usually are—great for stock/gravy).

Market Street — Georgia & Coulter

  • Best for: strong frozen selection and occasional fresh drops right before the holiday; easy one-stop for tools (thermometer, brine kits, pans).

  • What you’ll typically see:

United Supermarkets & Amigos — Multiple locations

Inventory changes daily. A 60-second call to the meat counter beats a 60-minute store hop.

Don’t let the lingo give you the bird…

Raising & breed claims — what actually changes flavor/texture

  • Organic. Birds are raised on organic feed with antibiotics prohibited and required outdoor access. Expect clean, reliable turkey flavor; you’re mostly paying for production standards and auditing.

  • Free-range. The flock must have outdoor access, but time/space aren’t tightly defined. Flavor bump is modest; don’t assume it equals pasture.

  • Pasture-raised. More true outdoor time on pasture; often older, more active birds. Expect a more “turkey-forward” flavor and firmer texture.

  • Heritage/Heirloom. Traditional, slower-growing breeds with proportionally more dark meat and smaller breasts. Flavor is deeper; texture can be firmer—use butter, basting, or tenting to protect the breast.

Processing & prep cues — what changes how you cook

  • Brined / Self-basting / “Contains up to X% solution.” Injected with liquid (water/broth/fat + seasonings). These cook juicier but saltier—season less and skip long wet brines. Always check the % and ingredients

  • Air-chilled & retained water. Lower retained water helps browning and gives you more concentrated drippings. If crisp skin is your thing, seek air-chilled or labels that specify “no/low retained water.

  • Fresh vs Frozen (or “Previously Frozen”). “Fresh” has never been below 26°F; frozen is ≤0°F. Quality can be excellent either way—just plan thaw time.

  • Young / Hen / Tom. “Young” is under ~8 months (tender). “Hen” (usually smaller) vs “Tom” (larger) mostly signals size, not quality—choose by headcount and leftovers.

Mostly marketing — what not to overpay for

  • “Natural” (just minimal processing/no artificial ingredients)

  • “No hormones” (not allowed in poultry anyway)

  • “Cage-free” (relevant to eggs, not meat birds),

  • Farm-raised/Family farm,” “Non-GMO” (no GMO turkeys; at best refers to feed)

  • “Premium/Restaurant quality/All-natural” are puff terms with no standardized meaning for taste or tenderness.

Portion guide

  • Whole turkey (bone-in): 1–1¼ lb per adult

  • Bone-in breast: ¾–1 lb per adult

  • Boneless roast: ½–¾ lb per adult

  • Kids (<10): count as ½ adult
    Adjusters: want leftovers → +½ lb/person • lots of sides/light eaters → –¼ lb/person • solution-added birds → pick the high end of the range.

Cheat sheet

  • 4–6 ppl → 4–6 lb bone-in breast or 10–12 lb whole

  • 8–10 ppl → 12–16 lb whole or two bone-in breasts totaling 8–10 lb

  • 12–14 ppl → 16–20 lb whole or two 10–12 lb birds (faster/easier)

  • 16–20 ppl → two 12–14 lb birds (better than one giant)

Your call script

“Hi! I’m shopping for an uncooked turkey. Could you help me check a few details?

  1. Whole birds today — fresh or frozen? Which brands and weight ranges? What’s the largest you have right now?

  2. Standards — do you have Organic, Free-Range, Pasture-Raised, Heritage/Heirloom, Kosher/Halal options?

  3. Pre-treatment — do any labels say ‘contains up to X% solution,’ ‘basted,’ ‘self-basting,’ or brined? What’s the % and ingredients?

  4. Processing — any air-chilled birds, and do labels list low retained water? Are these USDA Grade A?

  5. Other cuts — bone-in breasts (sizes/brands), thighs/drums/tenderloins, or 93% ground available?

  6. Logistics — when is the next truck day/time for fresh arrivals, and can you hold a [target weight] until [pickup window]? Do you need a name/phone or deposit?

  7. Extras — do whole birds include neck/giblets, and do you stock brine kits/thermometers nearby?”

Got tips or deals we missed? Share your Thanksgiving intel on Instagram and follow Yellow City Table for the cooking timeline + carving guide dropping soon!

Megg Dunlap
Next

Amarillo Food Resources This Week (Nov 10–16):